Foster's vs Priced Right: Cayman Grocery Price Comparison
(Updated Mar 7)
We compared 750 products available at both Foster's and Priced Right using UPC barcode matching. Here's the verdict.
The Score
| Metric | Foster's | Priced Right |
|---|---|---|
| Win Rate | 62% | 38% |
| Cheaper On | 467 items | 283 items |
| Avg Price | $11.75 | $24.52 |
| Total Products | 15,085 | 2,600 |
Where Foster's Wins
Products where Foster's has the better price:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chaise Lounge Chair | $219.99 (Foster's) | $249.99 (Priced Right) | $30.00 (12%) |
| Price R Chicken Wings Frzn | $59.99 (Foster's) | $89.99 (Priced Right) | $30.00 (33%) |
| P/Right Whole Frozen Snapper | $55.99 (Foster's) | $74.99 (Priced Right) | $19.00 (25%) |
| Mistic Juice Drink, Tropical Fruit Punch 15.9 Fl Oz | $1.59 (Foster's) | $17.99 (Priced Right) | $16.40 (91%) |
| Price R Chicken Thighs Frzn | $38.99 (Foster's) | $54.99 (Priced Right) | $16.00 (29%) |
| Gorilla 3 Step Steel Ladders | $69.99 (Foster's) | $84.99 (Priced Right) | $15.00 (18%) |
| San Pellegrino Sparkling Natural Mineral Water | $25.99 (Foster's) | $36.99 (Priced Right) | $11.00 (30%) |
| Badia Black Pepper, Ground 3.5 Lb | $28.99 (Foster's) | $39.99 (Priced Right) | $11.00 (28%) |
| Hillshire Farm Polska Kielbasa Smoked Sausage, Bundle Pack 56 Oz | $11.99 (Foster's) | $22.99 (Priced Right) | $11.00 (48%) |
| Hillshire Snacking Sausage, Smoked 4 Ea | $11.99 (Foster's) | $22.99 (Priced Right) | $11.00 (48%) |
| Chicken Drumsticks Frozen | $36.99 (Foster's) | $46.99 (Priced Right) | $10.00 (21%) |
| Gorilla 2 Step Ladder Steel | $54.99 (Foster's) | $64.99 (Priced Right) | $10.00 (15%) |
| Grace Mackerel In Tomato Sauce | $10.29 (Foster's) | $19.99 (Priced Right) | $9.70 (49%) |
| Ks Milk Choc Almond | $20.99 (Foster's) | $29.99 (Priced Right) | $9.00 (30%) |
| Cafe La Llave Coffee, Espresso, Fine Grind 4 Ea | $15.99 (Foster's) | $23.99 (Priced Right) | $8.00 (33%) |
Where Priced Right Wins
But it's not one-sided. These products are cheaper at the other store:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atomi Smart 2 Pack Light | $99.97 (Priced Right) | $149.99 (Foster's) | $50.02 (33%) |
| Muscle Mechanix Eliptical | $189.99 (Priced Right) | $219.99 (Foster's) | $30.00 (14%) |
| Ks Food Saver Vacum Bags Combo | $14.99 (Priced Right) | $34.99 (Foster's) | $20.00 (57%) |
| Google Smart Light Starter Kit 1 Kit | $24.99 (Priced Right) | $44.99 (Foster's) | $20.00 (44%) |
| Emeril Pizza Grill Small | $69.99 (Priced Right) | $89.99 (Foster's) | $20.00 (22%) |
| Four Elephants Jasmine Rice | $25.99 (Priced Right) | $39.99 (Foster's) | $14.00 (35%) |
| Stingray Band Kit | $14.99 (Priced Right) | $26.99 (Foster's) | $12.00 (44%) |
| Gerber Sitter 2nd Foods Fruit & Veggie Favorites Puree Blends Value Pack 12 Ea | $14.99 (Priced Right) | $23.99 (Foster's) | $9.00 (38%) |
| Kirkland Signature Mature Multi, Adult 50+, Tablets 400 Ea | $9.99 (Priced Right) | $18.99 (Foster's) | $9.00 (47%) |
| Sterilite Wastebasket Touchtop White | $12.99 (Priced Right) | $20.57 (Foster's) | $7.58 (37%) |
| Frappuccino Mocha Coffee Drink 15 Ea | $24.99 (Priced Right) | $31.99 (Foster's) | $7.00 (22%) |
| Wesson Canola Oil 5 Qt | $15.89 (Priced Right) | $22.49 (Foster's) | $6.60 (29%) |
| Ks Unsalted Butter Quarter 1 Lb | $13.99 (Priced Right) | $19.49 (Foster's) | $5.50 (28%) |
| Ks Salted Butter Quarters 1 Lb | $13.99 (Priced Right) | $19.49 (Foster's) | $5.50 (28%) |
| Petite Cuisine Mozzarella Sticks 5 Lb | $22.79 (Priced Right) | $27.99 (Foster's) | $5.20 (19%) |
Verdict
Foster's is cheaper on more items overall, but Priced Right beats them on plenty of products. The best strategy? Compare prices on the items you actually buy.
Based on 750 UPC-matched products. Prices updated daily.