Cost-U-Less vs Priced Right: Cayman Grocery Price Comparison
(Updated Mar 7)
We compared 93 products available at both Cost-U-Less and Priced Right using UPC barcode matching. Here's the verdict.
The Score
| Metric | Cost-U-Less | Priced Right |
|---|---|---|
| Win Rate | 43% | 57% |
| Cheaper On | 40 items | 53 items |
| Avg Price | $13.93 | $24.52 |
| Total Products | 821 | 2,600 |
Where Priced Right Wins
Products where Priced Right has the better price:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agrosuper Chkn Breast Bnls Sknls 10# | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $34.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $13.00 (37%) |
| Agrosuper Chicken Party Wings 10# | $22.99 (Priced Right) | $28.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $6.00 (21%) |
| Spam Luncheon Meat 6 12 | $17.99 (Priced Right) | $22.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $5.00 (22%) |
| Wf Almond Butter 27 | $9.99 (Priced Right) | $14.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $5.00 (33%) |
| Gain +Aroma Liq Lndry Dtrgnt 154 Oz | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $26.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $5.00 (19%) |
| Kellogg's Raisin Bran 76.5 | $9.99 (Priced Right) | $14.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $5.00 (33%) |
| Spam 25% Less Sodium 6-12< | $17.99 (Priced Right) | $22.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $5.00 (22%) |
| Kellogg's Froot Loops 43.6 | $8.99 (Priced Right) | $12.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $4.00 (31%) |
| Mcrmk Montreal Steak 29 | $10.99 (Priced Right) | $14.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $4.00 (27%) |
| Keebler Club Crkr Snks Stacks 24 Ct/50 | $11.99 (Priced Right) | $14.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $3.00 (20%) |
| Kellogg Frosted Flakes 61.9 | $11.99 (Priced Right) | $14.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $3.00 (20%) |
| Gm Cinnamon Toast Crunch 49.5 | $9.99 (Priced Right) | $12.98 (Cost-U-Less) | $2.99 (23%) |
| Brunswick Sardines In Oil | $8.99 (Priced Right) | $11.49 (Cost-U-Less) | $2.50 (22%) |
| Arizona Variety Pack 24 20 Pet | $23.69 (Priced Right) | $25.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $2.30 (9%) |
| Badia Seasoned Salt 2# | $4.79 (Priced Right) | $6.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $2.20 (31%) |
Where Cost-U-Less Wins
But it's not one-sided. These products are cheaper at the other store:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pillsbury Crescent Rolls 4 Pk | $9.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $16.99 (Priced Right) | $7.00 (41%) |
| Trident Ak Salmon Burger Patty 12 Ct/3# | $29.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $36.69 (Priced Right) | $6.70 (18%) |
| Beefy Cheese Patties | $16.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $5.00 (23%) |
| Scott Bath Tissue 1000 Sheet 20 Roll | $22.98 (Cost-U-Less) | $26.99 (Priced Right) | $4.01 (15%) |
| Meow Mix Classic Favorites 36 2.75 | $29.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $33.99 (Priced Right) | $4.00 (12%) |
| Gorton's Crunchy Panko Fish Sticks 56 | $17.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $4.00 (18%) |
| Red Baron Deep Dish Pizza 12 Ct/64 | $18.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $22.99 (Priced Right) | $4.00 (17%) |
| Tyson Breaded Chicken Nuggets 5# | $18.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $22.99 (Priced Right) | $4.00 (17%) |
| Duracell D Batteries 8 Ct | $14.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $18.99 (Priced Right) | $4.00 (21%) |
| Otis Spnkmyr Indwrpd Variety Muffins 60 | $18.49 (Cost-U-Less) | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $3.50 (16%) |
| Tasters Chc Nescafe Instant Coffee 14 | $19.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $22.99 (Priced Right) | $3.00 (13%) |
| Nestle Semi Sweet Morsels 72 | $18.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $3.00 (14%) |
| Totino's Pizza Rolls Triple Chse 160 Ct | $19.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $21.99 (Priced Right) | $2.00 (9%) |
| Clorox Disinfecting Wipes 5 85 Ct | $22.99 (Cost-U-Less) | $24.99 (Priced Right) | $2.00 (8%) |
| Armour Eckrich Deli Cooked Meatballs 4# | $17.49 (Cost-U-Less) | $19.49 (Priced Right) | $2.00 (10%) |
Verdict
Priced Right is cheaper on more items overall, but Cost-U-Less beats them on plenty of products. The best strategy? Compare prices on the items you actually buy.
Based on 93 UPC-matched products. Prices updated daily.